World Beer Festival, Durham, 2011

These are my notes from this year. I didn’t take very detailed notes, because I, in a fit of talent and rushing out the door, forgot both my pen and my carefully-planned list of booths I wanted to hit. I managed to recreate it on my phone, at least. A bit of a pain in the ass, but what can you do?

Unibroue, Quebec, Canada: Don de Dieu (tripel) I tried this toward the end of the night, and I remember it being good. Fruity and sweet, like most tripels.

Legend Brewing, Richmond, VA: Tripel: nice, drinkable. Quad: fucking amazing. I passed this one around, and everyone liked it (even Ben, who isn’t into quads), then I had to get more, because I didn’t have any left.

Kind Beers, Charlotte, NC: Belgian Style red ale: Mo got this, and I had a sip. It was awful. Very bitter and unpleasant.

North Coast Brewing Co, Fort Bragg, CA: La Merle (Belgian specialty ale): It was fruity and pleasant, and it had a thick mouthfeel. I had a sip of Enne’s Brother Thelonious (Belgian dark strong ale), and it was as good as I remembered it.

Kuhnhenn Brewing Co, Warren, MI: I wanted to try their White Devil (imperial white), but they didn’t have it. The imperial creme brulee java stout was really good, though it had a strong coffee bitterness (unlike the Southern Tier creme brulee stout). So I tried the Simcoe Silly (Belgian/American hybrid) and strongly disliked it.

Timmermans Brouwerij, Dilbeer-Itterbeek, Belgium: Bourgougne des Flanders (Flanders brown ale). When I got the sample, the pourer said, “It’s sour, just warning you.” I told him I drink straight Berliner Weisse, which is really damn sour, so bring it on. This was easily my favorite beer of the night, with Legend’s quad in a very close second. It wasn’t very sour; I’d argue that it’s not sour at all, but someone who doesn’t enjoy sour beers might disagree. [Interestingly, Belgian whites/wit beers are also technically sour beers, though I don't find them sour at all. I can kind of taste it if I think about it while drinking one. Lambics are another popular sour style.] It had a fruity note to it, and a heavy, thick mouthfeel. Very, very nice.

Mystery Brewing, Hillsborough, NC. I sponsored their Kickstarter project last year or the year before, so I had to go try their beer. I tried the Langhorne (rye wit), and it was odd. It tasted like a wit, but it had an unfamiliar note to it, which was the rye. I’d try it again to see if I liked it. Sadly, the beer we all wanted to try, the Six Impossible Things chocolate breakfast stout, had fallen victim to a catastrophic beersplosion. Ben got the Queen Anne’s Revenge (black IPA), and I think he said he hated it less than other black IPAs he’d tried. (Neither of us is a fan of IPAs in general; they’re victim to the American craft brewers’ belief that MOAR HOPS is better. Yuck.)

Bull City Burger and Brewery, Durham, NC. Pro Bono Publico (porter): All I have written down is “bitter.”

Aviator Brewing Company, Fuquay Varina, NC. Devil’s Tramping Ground (tripel). I don’t know if the batch was off or if it had gotten skunked (or if they gave me the wrong one), but this was very unpleasant. It wasn’t like a tripel at all.

Roth Brewing, Raleigh, NC. Forgotten Hollow cinnamon porter: I still love this beer. I first tried it when I went to the Flying Saucer one time when my dad was in town and they had it on draft. It’s kind of like drinking autumn. Their Dark Construct stout was nice, though it’s not going to be my new favorite stout. Ben really enjoyed it.

Palm Brouwerij, Steenhuffel, Belgium. Palm (Belgian amber ale). Dear readers, I poured this one out.

Boulevard Brewing Co, Kansas City, MO. The Sixth Glass (quadrupel): Not as nice as the Legend quad, but it still had a good flavor and modest sweetness to it.

Holy Mackerel Beers, Fort Lauderdale, FL. Panic Attack (Belgian Strong): very sweet, thick mouthfeel. Special Golden Ale: good, but not as sweet.

Anderson Valley Brewing Company, Boonville, CA. Winter Solstice (seasonal ale): tasted like Christmas spiced cider. It was really good. This would probably be my third favorite new beer.

Number of beers sampled: 18 (plus refills on two of them, one of them twice…)
Top three samples: Timmerman’s Bourgogne des Flanders; Legend’s quad; Anderson Valley’s Winter Solstice.

Posted in beer | Tagged | 7 Comments

Movie review: Space Battleship Yamato (2010 live action)

I imprinted on Leiji Matsumoto’s works at a very early age. I was about 5 (we only had HBO for a year), and I was watching the cartoons they showed one day. There was a kid, a space train, and this woman with long blonde hair, which was all I could remember about it until I found a VHS (remember those?) of Galaxy Express 999 at Suncoast (remember them?) when I was in college. Those were the days when you had to pay extra for the “collector’s edition,” which was Japanese audio with subtitles, because those letters were really expensive.

Back in the 80s, Matsumoto’s other main work, Space Battleship Yamato, was dubbed into English and shown on American TV as Star Blazers, renaming ace pilot Kodai Susumu to Derek Wildstar. (I almost put Rick Hunter there, but that’s what Ichijou Hikaru ended up as in Robotech, the US adaptation of Macross.) This fan site has plot summaries.

Last December, the live action movie was released in theaters, starring quite a few famous Japanese actors like Kimura Takuya (from the J-drama and movie Hero, about a lawyer, among other things). They made a few changes, notably making Dr Sado, of the bottle of sake and large orange cat, a woman, making it a little less of a sausage-fest. Still, there are only three named women on the Yamato: Sado, Mori Yuki, and the one whose name I forget but who’s one of the Black Tigers.

It’s the year 2199, and about five years ago, meteor bombs started hitting the Earth, making the surface too irradiated to live on and sending people underground to try to eke out a living. Humanity is fighting off Gamilas attacks, and everything they do, the Gamilas adapt to counter them. Captain Okita is leading an assault/defense force at Mars, and the Gamilan fleet is too strong for their weaponry. Kodai Mamoru, captain of the Yukikaze, uses his ship as a shield to allow Okita to escape and take the news to Earth.

Kodai Susumu is a scavenger. He goes out looking for metal to take to the military. While he’s out scavenging, a strange object falls from the sky and knocks off his protective gear. He picks it up and mysteriously survives the deadly radiation levels. At the same time, Okita’s ship returns. He takes the object to the military, and they examine it and find coordinates for planet Iscandar, where the Gamilas come from, and blueprints for a warp engine and a powerful weapon, the wave motion gun.

The leader of the military decides to send the Yamato out to Iscandar to find a decontamination device, which would allow people to move back to the surface, and Kodai joins up again. He’d been an ace pilot at the time of the initial Gamilan attacks, but he left after a personal tragedy. He is angry at Okita, because he believes Okita sacrificed his brother in order to escape. He meets up with his old buddies, the Black Tigers.

The name for the ship wasn’t chosen at random. The Yamato was a WW2 battleship that was sent on a mission to defend Okinawa until it was destroyed, to give the Japanese people a last hope (as Kodai explains in a speech at the end). Pasting from wikipedia, Yamato’s symbolic might was such that some Japanese citizens held the belief that their country could never fall as long as the ship was able to fight. The word Yamato also carries significance in Japan as a poetic name for the country and remains as a metaphor for the end of the empire.

While they’re in transit, they’re repeatedly attacked by Gamilan forces, and when they eventually make it to Iscandar, they find something unexpected. I won’t spoil the ending, but I saw it coming, because I’ve seen the old anime movies.

At times, it’s goofy. I couldn’t help but laugh at the Star Trek-like “the bridge is shaking, everybody lean to the right and look like you’re hanging on” effects, but the CG was really nice. I couldn’t figure out why they made a land assault at Iscandar rather than stay in their nice ships, other than to allow for heroism and sacrifice. The zero-g-love scene made me giggle (mainly because it put this song in my head). But it’s based on one of the classics of science fiction anime, and even as it changes and updates a few things (like the Gamilans being energy beings (they’re still blue, though) and the Cosmo Zero having something like a Valkyrie’s Gerwalk mode, probably just because it looks cool), it’s still the story Matsumoto wrote at its core.

It’s worth seeing, if you know how to get hold of it. There’s no word yet of an English release.

Posted in anime, movies, review | Tagged , , | Leave a comment

Back from Dragon*Con

I’ve actually been back since Monday evening, but Tuesday my lack of sleep caught up with me in the form of a low-grade migraine (sinus pressure, headache, no appetite, mild sensitivity to light), and yesterday I had to get back into my normal routine.

I had a lot of fun, as usual, though there weren’t as many panels or people I wanted to see this year. Yeah, they had Tom Felton (Draco Malfoy), but he wasn’t my favorite, and I don’t think he could top Matthew Lewis’ panel from a few years ago. I really enjoyed Eric Flint’s panel in the alternate history track about Marxism. It was a guided discussion (by a moderator, who asked questions like “How does your Marxism influence your writing?” and “How do you portray class in your works?”) between him and SM Stirling (who is very much not a Marxist), which was incredibly interesting. It gave me a few things to think about for my writing.

This year I watched the parade, which I hadn’t done in any of the previous five years I’ve gone. It’s a great way to see a lot of cool costumes without much effort. Also, the whole lot of Stormtroopers bringing up the rear (yay, 501st) is a really impressive sight.

I also got my copy of Shades of Milk and Honey signed.

There weren’t a whole lot of shiny things for me in the dealers halls, though I bought a t-shirt from an artist’s table (it was tan! with a cute kitsune on it!) and two model kits from Gundam 00. And a statue of Ozma Lee’s Valkyrie from Macross Frontier. Not much else really jumped out at me.

I really enjoy going to Dragon*Con; it’s a 4-day nerd party, where you don’t get judged for wanting to dress up like Superman or Batman or Zatanna or Captain Harlock or a space Marine or an alien or a zombie, vampire, werewolf, or Macho Man Randy Savage or … you get the point. It’s getting ridiculous to get hotel rooms; rumor has it the Hilton is already sold out for next year (though I’m skeptical of that). The Marriott and Hyatt sell out within hours of the block opening.

I want to attend a World Con sometime soon, but, annoyingly, the next two are Labor Day weekend. Not that I could afford to go to both even if they were different weekends, mind. 2012 is going to be in Chicago, 2013 in San Antonio. 2014 hasn’t been voted on yet, but London’s bid is unopposed. I can’t afford to go to London, and being in London is extremely expensive (especially since it’s usually 2 pounds to the dollar, and a sit-down meal will cost you 20 pounds or so). I’m not super excited about San Antonio; it’s Labor Day weekend. Atlanta is hot enough, and I don’t want to go someplace hotter. Which means Chicago next year is the likeliest option in the near future. I’ve never really visited Chicago, and depending on how things work out with the hotel and travel days, we could have a short vacation there.

Which leads to an additional problem. My oldest cat, Isis, is an evil tortie, and she has diabetes. The cat sitter we hired for last weekend had so much trouble with Her Evilness that she had to bring a second person to help hold her to get her shot, for which we owe her additional monies. It stressed Isis out badly enough that she must have had a sugar spike, because she was sick when we got home and is on two different antibiotics right now. She doesn’t hate our usual cat sitter, but she’s got a second job now, which gives her crazy hours, so she’s not always available. Maybe by next year, she’ll have enough seniority not to get the shit hours.

We need to decide fairly quickly, though. Memberships are $175 each right now, and the price goes up October 1. Blech. (I understand why they’re so expensive: each World Con committee has only one chance to recoup their costs for guest transport, hotel rental, etc. I can still think it’s too damned expensive.)

Posted in cons | Tagged | 1 Comment

Book review: When the Tide Rises

When the Tide Rises, David Drake. 2008, Baen Books.

This is the sixth novel in Drake’s RCN series. I haven’t read any of the previous books, but that didn’t make much difference, as far as I can tell. Perhaps I missed some of the in-jokes or references, but that’s not a big deal. It stands well on its own.

In the introduction, Drake cites the memoirs of Lord Cochrane as his source/inspiration for these books. This is the same memoir that Patrick O’Brian used for his Aubrey/Maturin books, so they bear a lot of similarity.

Commander Daniel Leary is in the employ of the Republic of Cinnabar Navy, and he’s assigned to a planet that’s declared independence from the Alliance, Cinnabar’s enemy. He makes a stop at Diamondia, a planet under siege by Alliance forces, to check in with the man in charge there and see what the most recent intel is.

Adele Mundy, Leary’s signals officer and librarian-hacker-spy, meets a young man who’s the grandson of her mentor. His parents have just been killed by the head of the Alliance, and he wants her help. She brings him along on the trip, even though her sociopathic servant and bodyguard Tovera thinks it’s a bad idea.

Once they arrive at Bagaria, Leary is enjoined to the Bagarian fleet, and he commands them in a few raids in Alliance space. There are crosses and double-crosses, and politicking, and hardcore librarian spying.

There are a lot of details about the ships and sailing, and I will admit I skimmed them. I found it odd that starships had literal sailing masts and rigging, but it fit the book itself. I’m not sure what the sails were made of (probably described in more detail in earlier books in the series), though I remember mention of it being very thin. (Nanomaterial?) I will say that it’s disheartening to read about a ship with the name of your football club (which itself is named for a ship) being sunk a few hours before they’re set to take the pitch. (Sports fans are a superstitious lot. We won, btb, for the first time this season.)

There’s a lot of adventure, and I really liked the hardcore traumapast librarian. If you read the Aubrey/Maturin books (Master and Commander, etc) and thought, “You know what these books need? Spaceships,” the RCN series is for you. If you like Bujold’s Vorkosigan books and don’t mind fine attention to sailing detail, you might enjoy them, too.

The first three books are available at the Baen Free Library, beginning with With the Lightnings.

Posted in books, review | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Book review: 1632

1632, by Eric Flint. 2000, Baen. Available in print and at the Baen Free Library

The premise behind 1632 and its sequels is that a mining town in West Virginia from the year 2000 is magically swapped with an equal-sized piece of land in Thuringia in 1632. The Americans are dropped in the middle of the Thirty Years’ War, during which the Catholic Holy Roman Empire was doing its level best to wipe out the Protestants.

Mike Stearns, a union organizer and UMWA member, organizes a militia to defend their town and the neighboring towns. Their personal gun collections are vastly superior to the arquebuses of the 17th century, so they have quick, decisive victories, until they get embroiled in the greater conflict surrounding them.

Flint goes into a good bit of detail about how the town residents can scale their existing level of technology–electricity, internal combustion engines, etc–down to something more sustainable with the resources available to them in the mid-17th century. He also goes into a good bit of detail about the military history and manouevres.

There’s a very strong “Wooo! USA!” jingoism to the book, but it’s a leftish sort of jingoism, focused on equality, freedom of religion, and worker’s rights. From someone of Flint’s background (former labor organizer and member of the Socialist Workers’ Party), that’s not too surprising.

There were several not-so-subtle digs at Americans, including remarks from 1632-era characters like “Americans don’t know how to cook without a ton of meat,” and “Why do they think walking everywhere is such a horrible thing?” which I found rather apt. He also takes a few digs at institutionalized sexism.

The best marksman in town is a high school senior named Julie. Before they got bamfed back to the 17th century, she was training for the Olympic biathlon qualification. She takes her shiny rifle and joins a party to act as a sniper. Mike tells her it’s OK if she can’t bring herself to shoot people, and that even in the military, they let you drop out of sniping without prejudice. She ignores him and sets up her targets.

Finally, an expression came to her young, almost angelic face. But Mike couldn’t quite interpret it. Sarcasm? No, it was more like whimsy; or maybe, wry amusement.

“Did Uncle Frank ever tell you the story,” she asked, “about the first time I went deer hunting? How I cried like a baby after I shot my first buck?”

Mike nodded. Julie’s expression grew very wry.

“You know why? The deer was so pretty. And it had never done me any harm.” Julie cocked her head toward her observer, a girl no older than she. Another recent high-school graduate. Slender, where Julie was not, but otherwise—peas from a pod.

“Hey, Karen! Those guys look pretty to you?”

Karen shifted her gum into a corner of her mouth. “Nope. Ugly bastards. Mean looking, too. Look more like wild dogs than cute little deer.”

Julie bared her teeth. The smile was far more savage than anything belonging on the face of an eighteen-year-old, male or female. “That’s what I thought. Hey, Karen! Watcha think they’ll do—to you and me, I mean—if they get their hands on us?”

Karen was back to chewing her gum. Her words came out in a semimumble. “Don’t want to think about it, girl. But I’ll tell you one thing. Won’t be trying to sweet-talk us into the backseat of a car. Not likely.”

The smile left Julie’s face; but, if anything, the sense of whimsy was even stronger in her eyes. She gave Mike a level gaze.

“That’s the whole problem with allowing men into combat,” she said solemnly. “You guys are just too emotional about the whole thing.”

Overall, I enjoyed the book, even though I had some quibbles with the German. (“Thank God” is three words in German, not two, and it’s not “Danke Gott,” but “Gott sei Dank.” Threw me out of the story both times it came up. This is not likely to be a problem for most readers, however.) There were some stylistic quirks that bothered me, but not enough to make me stop reading. If you like alternate history and military fiction, with some focus on the characters, you might like this. (And it’s available free online, so giving the first few chapters a go won’t cost you anything beyond your usual internet fee.)

Posted in books, review | Tagged , | 2 Comments

Off to Dragon*Con!

In the morning, anyway. I’ve got my stuff together, clothes and food and a book to get signed, and we’re driving off in the morning.

I’ll be reading with Broad Universe at 10 pm Friday in Greenbriar (Hyatt). Come say hi!

Posted in cons | Tagged | 1 Comment

Book review: Jump Gate Twist

Jump Gate Twist, Mark L. Van Name. Baen Books, 2010.

This omnibus collects the first two Jon & Lobo books, One Jump Ahead and Slanted Jack, and two short stories, “My Sister, My Self,” and “Lobo, Actually.” The author has written intros and afterwords for each section of the book, which reveal some insight into the writing of each tale.

One Jump Ahead starts with Jon attempting to take a vacation, but, thanks to a careless indiscretion, he’s hired to rescue a man’s daughter from her kidnappers. One of the local heads of a vast, interplanetary conglomerate is trying to get sole usage rights to the planet Jon’s vacationing on, and the other major vast, interplanetary conglomerate is angling for the same thing, so the daughter is kidnapped. Except Jon ends up entangled in a plot that is a lot more complicated than that, and he seeks the aid of his former employer, the Saw, a mercenary outfit.

In “My Sister, My Self,” Jon loses the person who means the most to him: his sister, Jennie. But not before she “fixes” him. The events in this story are referenced throughout the rest of Jon’s stories, and this gives us some insight into his life on Pinkelponker before he’s taken to Dump Island (see Children No More).

Slanted Jack is a con artist who used to be Jon’s partner in crime, and he waltzes into Jon’s life with a request to help this boy who’s a descendent of people from Pinkelponker. Of course it doesn’t turn out to be so easy, and Jon ends up tangling with arms smugglers, the colonial governing bodies, and the followers of a religion based on Pinkelponker, as well as Jack.

“Lobo, Actually,” is a Christmas story told by the AI of a Predator-Class Armored Vehicle: Jon’s ship, Lobo, but before he’s Jon’s ship. A young boy’s father is dying of an illness that’s going around their planet, because the hospitals don’t have the cure. Lobo feels something like pity for him, though it’s partly also boredom from being stuck in the town square as their pet scarecrow.

All together, the stories that comprise Jump Gate Twist are enjoyable. They’re full of action and adventure, with politics creeping up the side. Jon himself isn’t political, but the structural politics of the universe he inhabits are visible as he maneuvers through them. If you like adventure stories (in space!), pick up this book.

Posted in books, review | Tagged , | 1 Comment

My Online Life

There has been much discussion about pseudonymity and real-name policies in the wake of Google+ (I’m on it! Come say hello!), and what expectations different groups have for online interactions.

I didn’t meet the internet until I started college. I didn’t get email until I started college. I’d guess about half my peer group (Gen X) was about the same, though among my friends (geeks with a high fraction of CS/math/physics types), I was late to the party. They had 512 baud dialup to BBSes and whatever. I couldn’t figure out how to play Oregon Trail on the high school computers. I’m sort of the generation that had a lot of formative experiences in meat-space before the internet really took off. (I know people who are a decade younger than me who say they’re “from the internet.”)

Yet I have many friends online, some of whom I’ve never met in person, but I see pictures of their kids or pets on facebook or twitter. I received a box full of Turkish media (books and DVDs) in English from an almost-complete stranger who offered to send me some things to help me understand Turkish culture better. (I was expecting, like a book or 2. I got 5 plus 3 DVDs.) I commented that I love German Christmas foods, and an acquaintance sent me a care package full of marzipan and Lebkuchen and hazelnut chocolate. I hope someday to return the favor, or pay it forward to someone else.

I have friends who I met online and have become close friends, with whom I share trials and joys, to whom I offer support and congratulations. Some of them I’ve since met in person, but many, possibly even most, I haven’t.

I met my husband via the internet, through some people I met in person who had an IRC channel they hung out on and a mailing list.

Thanks to twitter and the German football league, I have casual friends who live in Norway, Pakistan, Egypt, and Bangladesh, as well as Germany and various places in the US and Canada. I talk with fans of my club team on twitter, and the next time I make it to Berlin, I’ll see about meeting some of them in person. (To catch a match at the stadium or in a bar, whatever.)

I’ve been online for seventeen years now, close to half my life. I became more involved in the internet about thirteen years ago, when I met the people with the IRC channel. I’ve had a dozen online identities since then, on mailing lists, general forums, topic-oriented forums, blogs, communities. I currently have seven different handles online, some more public than others. I don’t make it a secret that @exaggerated and @strafraum are both me, but @exaggerated is where I put pictures of my cats and links to my blog, and @strafraum is where I talk about (FIFA) football.

Where was I going with this? Right. I think online is where a lot of people have formative experiences, develop deep friendships, and generally interact with other like-minded individuals. It’s so much easier now than it was twenty years ago to find other people who like reading/writing the same kind of stories you do. I’ve wondered so many times how my high school life would have been different if I’d had access to the internet, or even known that there were other people out there who liked SF/F. (A much less trivial aspect is that LGBTQ teens in small towns can find support online through various communities and know that they’re not alone.)

Oftentimes, these experiences take place under a pseudonym, a handle. The handle, once used long enough, becomes as real as the name on the driver’s license or birth certificate. It’s a name we choose, not the name we are given, and that’s as real to us as the name our parents chose for us at birth — and sometimes more real. People legally change their names for a variety of reasons, and whether it’s because they hate their birth name or because they’re transgender and their birth name is wrong, those are equally valid reasons.

The first link in this post discusses who is harmed by real-name policies. The answer is anyone who is outside the societally-accepted norm.

Posted in meta | Tagged | Leave a comment

ReaderCon 22 writeup: No Childhood Left Behind

I haven’t seen any other writeups on this panel yet, and, of course, this is one I didn’t take ~excellent~ notes on. (I was always a poor note-taker in school, preferring to rely on vague suggestions to jog my memory.) I have just over 2 pages, mostly attributed. The discussion wandered some, and I had a hard time keeping up with it at times.

Panelists: Leah Bobet, Chris Moriarty, Sonya Taaffe, ? Wilber, JoSelle Vanderhooft

Taaffe introduced the panel and the topic, and there was a brief discussion about what each panelist thought the panel was about. Someone mentioned in their introduction that one aspect of the panel description involved the old standards, and I have two unattributed paraphrased comments.
- Problematic old standards are the books people keep reading
- socialization and the ossification of SF culture

Question: Is there a YA canon/classics?
Bobet: It’s what people decided to read when they were kids; it doesn’t reflect reality more than other canons do (eg high school/college Literary Canon)
Wilber: All post-WW2 SF was written for youth, specifically boys. It was full of American optimism, which changed in the 60s as the boys grew up and found women, and we learned that America isn’t always right. It’s gone in a new direction.
Taaffe: Are there books you’d consider canon (ie, that you and a lot of people read as a kid) but don’t want to admit? Is Piers Anthony canon? (many groans and laughs from the audience and panel)
Moriarty: There’s not really a canon, just a nebulous list of things that a critical mass of people admit they have read. There’s a big wall between YA and SF (in bookstores & many libraries), leading to ossification. Are we losing the next generation because they aren’t being shown the SF that exists?
audience: when I was young, we only had Asimov & Heinlein.
Wilber: pays attention to what his teenaged daughter reads. lately it’s been Scott Westerfeld.
Bobet: Segregation is an SF cultural thing. SF readers are smarter, special (different), and we don’t need YA SF because kids go straight to adult books. We did this to ourselves.
Moriarty agrees.
Wilber: read adult SF of the day, which could be classed as YA today because there was no strong language or sex
Bobet: The emotional age of the books matters. The Belgariad (not marketed as YA) is perfect for a childhood understanding of the world
Vanderhooft: Is this segregation a result of the (recent) American fear of science?
Taaffe: There was a brief period in the 40s where scientists were heroes. Eleanor Campbell’s “Boy in the Mushroom Cloud” (?) had a mad scientist who wasn’t evil or comic relief
Wilber: US and UK SF diverged in the 50s, and they haven’t converged again.
audience: Is the older Asimov-Heinlein canon relevant to today’s youth? How do we recommend books to kids?
Bobet: we have our heads up our asses on this.
[crosstalk]
audience: there’s a difference between YA books kids like and ones adults like.
audience (librarian): once we stopped taking award winners (and started choosing based on recommendation?) circulation went up
audience: young people today have a lot of shared experiences, books they all talk about
Moriarty: adult canon – a bunch of old books approved by academics, but youth canon changes in waves with generations
audience: isn’t canon what you need to have read to understand the rest of literature? (gave example about the bible and much western lit) Especially in a grenre like SF that often responds to its predecessors?
Moriarty: not as much a problem in fantasy as it is in hard SF, which is very referential
Wilber: it becomes exclusive
[rambling audience comment led into digression about definition of YA and the Library of Congress]
audience: interested in moving canon, read OZ but not many people recently have read them. They were the Harry Potter or Twilight of their day; there are problematic representations as well as things like dropped subplots
Taaffe: E Nesbitt is great, until you hit the anti-Semitism
Bobet: reread a book about an orphanage and realized it was about eugenics (missed title)
audience: moving canon as a gateway drug
audience: kids & YA totally separate, SF was restricted in the 60s, we’ve come full circle and it’s exclusive again
audience: how much of this debate is because SFF sealed itself off from YA?
Bobet: all of it. It’s an in-group/out-group marker, and it has become a mainstream thing (Harry Potter, manga, etc) w/kids, and it resulted in a different worldview. They don’t worry about jocks stuffing them in a locker.


I thought this topic was interesting, because I wasn’t raised by a fan. I wasn’t exposed to much of what my peer group (SFF fans between about 27 and 40) read as kids/teens until I was out of college, sometimes WELL out of college. I read Narnia, the Hobbit, and LOTR by the time I was 10 (I read LOTR in 5th grade), and I read the Belgariad and its sequel series in middle school, and the first three Shannara books when my grandma bought them for me at the used book shop. I found Madeleine L’engel in the school library, then moved on to LeGuin (they were next to each other) and Earthsea, but after that, nothing. I didn’t read Ender’s Game until I was 23 or 24 (and wasn’t impressed, really), and The Dark is Rising I read while I was on my residency — at 30. I’d never heard of Diana Wynne Jones (RIP) until the Studio Ghibli adaptation of Howl’s Moving Castle came out.

In a way I feel cheated, I suppose, because I don’t have that shared experience, and anybody who’s spent ten minutes in SF fandom knows that shared experience is THE fannish shibboleth. But spending time on could have beens is futile. I guess it’s a good thing that there isn’t a true canon for YA, or I’d have a lot of catching up to do, and I can’t even manage the current books I want to read.

Posted in books, cons | Tagged , , | 1 Comment

Bull Spec issue 6 is available

It’s got my review of Germline in it. You can get the pdf here (for free or a price you choose; suggested donation of $2).

I really liked the book, and I hope more people buy it and read it. If you like gritty military SF with a realistic set of politics in the background, you need to read Germline. It’s seriously amazing. It’s not pretty at times, but it feels true and honest, and the religion the genetically-engineered supersoldiers are fed — based on a cross between Christianity and the modern combat manual — is perfectly creepy.

If you want to know more of my thoughts on the matter, get the full issue. You can get it for free, if you like. (Though Sam’s a nice guy and is funding the entire thing out of his own money, so throw a little scratch his way.)

Posted in books, link, review | Tagged , , | Leave a comment